IC Day Is Your Performance Review

Every investment committee meeting is an audition. Your partners are evaluating not just the deal—they're evaluating your judgment. The associates who get promoted are the ones who walk into IC prepared for every question.

Here's how to make sure you're one of them.

Start Preparation 48 Hours Before

If you're scrambling the morning of IC, you've already lost. Two days before, you should have:

• Memo finalised and circulated — Give partners time to read it
• Data room reviewed — Know every document, even the ones you didn't include in the memo
• Reference calls completed — At least 3-4 references, including off-list ones
• Competitive analysis updated — Check for any recent news or funding announcements

Anticipate the Questions

Every partner has patterns. Learn them. But here are the questions that come up in virtually every IC:

• "Why will this team win?" — Have specific evidence, not just credentials
• "What's the bear case?" — If you can't articulate it, you haven't done the work
• "Why this valuation?" — Benchmark against comparable deals. Tools like Predict Ventures can give you instant data on how similar companies were valued at the same stage
• "What happens if [key assumption] is wrong?" — Run the sensitivity analysis beforehand
• "Who else is in the round?" — Know the full syndicate and why they're interested

Structure Your Presentation

Don't just walk through the memo page by page. Structure your presentation for impact:

1. Hook (1 minute): Why this deal is exciting in one sentence
2. Context (2 minutes): Market backdrop and why now
3. Company deep dive (5 minutes): Team, traction, differentiation
4. Risks and mitigants (3 minutes): Show you've stress-tested the thesis
5. Recommendation and terms (2 minutes): Clear ask with return scenarios

Total: 13 minutes. Leave time for discussion.

Prepare Your Back-Pocket Slides

Build 5-10 appendix slides you hope you won't need but probably will. Detailed financial model, customer cohort data, competitive feature comparison, org chart, cap table summary. When a partner asks a tough question and you can pull up the exact answer, it signals thoroughness.

Handle Pushback Gracefully

When a partner challenges your thesis, don't get defensive. The best responses follow this pattern:

1. Acknowledge the concern genuinely
2. Share what you found when you investigated it
3. Explain why you still believe the investment thesis holds (or concede the point)

Partners respect associates who can hold a position under pressure while remaining intellectually honest.

After IC: Close the Loop

Whether the deal gets approved or passed, follow up within 24 hours:

• Send a summary of the decision and any follow-up items
• If approved: outline the next steps and timeline for closing
• If passed: document the reasons so the firm has a record of its decision-making
• If conditional: clarify exactly what additional diligence is needed and by when

The Long Game

IC isn't just about individual deals. Over time, your track record at IC builds (or erodes) your internal credibility. Be selective about what you bring. It's better to present 3 strong deals per quarter than 10 mediocre ones. Your partners will learn to pay attention when you speak.

---

Make Smarter Investment Decisions

Stop relying on gut feel. Predict Ventures benchmarks every startup against 15,000+ data points and 50 years of exit history to give you a quantitative edge.

Run your first free report →